Your newsletter on applied creativity, imagination, ideas and innovation in
business – delivered to your e-mail box on the first and third Tuesday
of every month.
Tuesday, 21 June 2005
Hello and welcome to another issue of Report 103, your fortnightly newsletter
on creativity, imagination, ideas and innovation in business.
As always, if you have news about creativity, imagination, ideas, or innovation
please feel free to forward it to me for potential inclusion in Report103. Your
comments and feedback are also always welcome.
Information on unsubscribing, archives, reprinting articles, etc can be found
at the end of this newsletter.
CREATIVE INVESTMENT: SPREADING THE CREATIVITY
I saw the latest Star Wars film, Revenge of the Siths, the other day. The special
effects were stunning. The film was rich with all kinds of realistic inventions,
floating vehicles, spaceships, weapons and much more. Moreover, the detail –
down to the mud stains – was incredible.
Sadly, the story, plot and characterisation all lacked the creativity of the
special effects. And while I was overwhelmed by the special effects (I'm one
of those rare birds who sits up at the front of a cinema so that the screen
fills my field of view and I can admire the detail work), I was actually bored
by the film itself.
The problem with Revenge of the Siths is that George Lucas and company invested
the bulk of their creativity in the special effects, rather than in the story
and character development. In the end, of course, Mr. Lucas will make sacks
full of money on his latest film – so it can hardly be classified as a
failure. But it could have been so much better.
Poorly invested creativity is a problem in business too. While many firms invest
creativity in developing new products and services, they often focus the creativity
on a single aspect of their product: cool design but dull functionality; dull
overall concept but innovative detail work; or innovative product but lacklustre
marketing campaign which fails to promote product adequately.
In industry, two examples come to mind of products which demonstrated a great
deal of creativity poorly invested in one aspect of the product development.
Both are now defunct European car manufacturers: Daf and NSU.
Daf was a Dutch manufacturer of cars and trucks – and they still make
highly regarded trucks today. In 1959, Daf introduced their first car and it
featured their highly innovative Variomatic automatic transmission. Without
going into excessive detail, a typical automatic transmission includes 3-5 gears
and a torque converter which “feels” the torque going from the engine
to the wheels and upshifts or downshifts gears appropriately. The Variomatic
transmission, on the other hand, comprises two cone shaped gears and a belt
that runs between them. The Variomatic automatically selects the best position
of the belt between the two gears for optimum efficiency. The result is a phenomenally
smooth automatic transmission Moreover, it was far more efficient than automatic
transmissions of the time.
Unfortunately, while the Variomatic transmission was – and still is –
a very innovative and efficient approach to automatic gearing, it was always
Daf cars' main innovative feature. So, while potential buyers may have been
intrigued by the Variomatic transmission – many were not compelled enough
by the rest of the car to buy one. Daf was eventually bought by Volvo.
NSU was a well established manufacturer based in Germany. They started producing
cars in the late 1950s and introduced the first Wankel rotary engined car in
1960. The rotary engine uses a huge, fast moving rotor where normal cars use
pistons, to move the car.
NSU made the same mistake as Daf. They invested too much of their creativity
on one component of their product: the engine. And while the Wankel engine theoretically
is more efficient and simpler than the piston engine, NSU did not focus enough
on quality control and so their motors were notoriously unreliable. Add the
fact that cars that were otherwise uninnovative, and it is understandable why
the public did not buy up NSUs in droves. Sadly, when NSU did put together an
all round innovative car – the then futuristic Ro 80 launched in 1967
– they still did not put much effort into the quality control of their
Wankel engines. As a result NSU did not make money on their car sales and were
eventually bought by Volkswagon.
The lesson to be learned here – if you are not George Lucas with a successful
film franchise behind you – is that when launching new products or services,
you need to invest creativity across every aspect of the product development
cycle: from initial concept, to pre-implementation development (concept, prototype,
market research, trial runs,etc) to development and even marketing. Yes, marketing
is critical too. After all, if you have the most innovative product in the world,
but market it badly, you will never sell it. Indeed, 3M's post-its almost didn't
succeed because the marketing team used their traditional industrial adhesive
marketing approach to market their new Post-its. It was only when a new team
introduced an innovative marketing approach that Post-its took off.
Needless-to-say, once the product hits the market, you cannot stop your creative
investment. You need to continually improve your product and the marketing of
your product to ensure sales growth.
Sticking to the motoring industry, two examples of companies that have successfully
invested innovation are Toyota and Citroen. Toyota cars may seem less than inspiring
to motoring aficionados. But, over the years, Toyota have introduced their fair
share of innovative cars and car features– generally targeting families,
young people or other groups. More importantly, Toyota have continually invested
in all aspects of their product development, from designing competitive cars
- that appeal in terms of practicality and reliability rather than sexiness
and outright performance – to devising and improving the just-in-time
Citroen has not been as successful as Toyota, and they are all but unknown
in the US market. But, until they were bought by Peugeot (also not well known
in the US market), Citroens were highly innovative cars designed by sculptures
and engineered by creative engineers. Citroens were always stunning looking
cars with incredible suspension systems and quirky functionality. Although Citroen
was eventually bought out by Peugeot, Citroen is still a successful brand and
part of their continual success is the result of their innovative history. Sadly,
however, Citroens now are not as exciting as they were in previous decades.
We shall see how this affects their future success.
The lesson is clear. If you want to reap the rewards of innovation, you have
to make a creative investment across the product development cycle.
In case you are interested, examples of Science fiction films which invested
creativity better than Revenge of the Siths, include: 2001: a Space Odyssey,
Forbidden Planet, Dark City and – of course – the original Star
CREATIVE INVESTMENTS: SOME BASIC CALCULATIONS
Creative investment in a project includes several cost points. The main one
being people. Breaking them down, we get...
Project workers: The main creative investment in any project is staff time
invested by the project workers in devising, developing, testing and implementing
ideas. Very rarely can a good idea be implemented immediately. Often there
is a need to develop and test ideas. For example, if a coffee mug designer
has the idea to replace the traditional coffee mug handle with a knob, she
will probably need to draw up some examples to see how the knob looks as
well as make some prototypes. Very likely she will find that it is very
hard not to spill a knobbed coffee mug when you hold it by the knob. Hence
the idea must either be further developed or dropped all together. This
testing and revising of ideas takes time.
Management approval: Most project teams must take their projects to senior
management for approval. Even autonomous project teams will normally want
to take radical ideas to top management to ensure their backing. Moreover,
when innovation new concepts are proposed, it often takes managers longer
to analyse the new ideas and approve them. This is because managers may
be reluctant to take on creative risk (see below) or simply because an innovative
new product or feature needs to be analysed in a different way than in the
Testing: Occasionally, a new idea is so obviously brilliant and a company
so dynamic that a bold new idea can be developed into a bold new product
and launched immediately. Very occasionally. More often, new ideas need
to be tested via prototypes and market research. Sometimes legislation or
ethics demand testing for safety or meeting specific industry standards.
Testing is often carried out by outside suppliers who specialise in such
Consultants, trainers and other outside thinkers: Consultants and other
service providers can often bring new ideas to projects as well as train
project workers to be more creative. Nevertheless, they do add cost to projects.
Tools and facilities: Tools such as Jenni idea management (http://www.jpb.com/jenni/)
which solicit, capture, evaluate and implement ideas generally improve the
cost effectiveness of capturing and evaluating new ideas. Nevertheless,
there is a cost investment in such tools. Likewise design tools, creativity
helpers, drawing paper, modelling clay, meeting facilities and other tools
and facilities are necessary for developing creative projects.
Before you panic and decide you cannot afford the creative investment necessary
to devise and develop innovative projects, bear in mind the rewards, which in
business is usually increased income which comes from either or both of these
Increased revenue: an innovative new product should result in increased
revenue as your firm earns more money from selling a product the competition
cannot match. If it is an all new product, there is a possibility of cornering
a new market. If it is an improved version of an existing product, there
is the possibility of capturing more market share as customers see your
product is so much better than the competitors'.
Cost savings: very often, the benefit of creative ideas is not increased
income, but reduced costs. If you can cut 10% from the cost of manufacturing
your product, that can result in a 10% increase in the revenue generated
by the product or the possibility to reduce pricing and undercut the competition
– or a combination of the above.
If additional creative investment always resulted in proportionately increased
income, the investment decision would be any easy one to make: invest as much
as you can. Unfortunately, creative new ideas also carry a creative risk. Sometimes
ideas are too radical for the market place. Sometimes, the creative investment
is too focused (see above article). Sometimes a concept that works well in the
prototype does not work so well in practice. Likewise, a cost-cutting idea may
prove more complicated – and thus more costly – to implement and
maintain than predicted.
As with any investment, creative investment carries a risk which must be analysed
accordingly. Unfortunately, the most radically creative ideas not only have
the greatest profit potential, but they are also the hardest to analyse as there
are few if any comparable predecessors that can be used as a basis for measuring
We'll look at analysing creative risk in a future issue of Report 103. But
I personally recommend taking the risk if the rewards are worth it and the consequences
are not devastating. But if things go wrong, don't blame me!
JENNI VERSION 2.1 OUT NOW
Jenni version 2.1 includes
a few new features that enhance usability.
Idea search: Jenni now boasts a more sophisticated search function that allows
you to locate ideas by key words or phrases in the idea or the title of the
Picture upload: Jenni now allows users to upload digital images that will appear
above the idea. Although Jenni has always allowed users to upload attached files
including images, the uploaded files have always been attachments whose links
users click on to see. Now an image can appear with an idea.
Genius Directory pictures: Jenni's genius directory is a directory of all users
of your Jenni implementation. The Genius Directory includes basic information
about users together with links to their most recent ideas. It is a great way
to learn more about – and network with - people who submit great ideas.
With version 2.1, users can upload pictures of themselves to the Genius Directory.
User search: Jenni's genius directory, user management, campaign participation
and other user interaction features can all now tap into Jenni's user search
function which allows you to search for people by name, surname, department
or location. This not only allows you to find people more easily, but also allows
the manager of an ideas campaign to monitor innovation performance by department,
location or individual.
By the way, because Jenni is a virtual software hosted on our servers, existing
clients will get the upgrade installed automatically over the next two weeks
– at no additional cost.
For more information about Jenni idea management, please visit http://www.jpb.com/jenni/.
INNOVATIVE CUSTOMERS DESIGNING THEIR OWN PRODUCTS
The Observer newspaper ran an interesting article this Sunday on customers
who design their own products. It includes case studies on mountain bikes, electronic
games and more. Read it at http://observer.guardian.co.uk/focus/story/0,6903,1509759,00.html
NEW SALES PARTNER IN NEW JERSEY
Also working with us is Dan Kenyon, president and founder of Gray Hare Sales,
a New Jersey, USA based sales consultancy. Gray Hare Sales and Consulting has
a multi-year history providing business consulting by developing sales and marketing
strategies that help our customers grow their business.
Dan will focus on developing the New Jersey and New York markets.
For more information about Gray Hare Consulting, please visit http://www.grayhareconsulting.com/
or contact Dan on +1 732-868-1139.
We work with a number of partners around the world in order to sell Jenni and,
more importantly, ensure our clients receive a high standard of service.
We are specifically looking for innovation consultants and trainers in the
USA and Canada who could provide support and training on a contract basis. Note
this is not an employment offer. We are looking for small firms and freelancers.
I am also always interested in sales partners who can bring Jenni to their
own markets (we have no in-house sales team and work exclusively with partners)
as well as other creativity and innovation professions with whom we can work
to mutual benefit.
If you like the idea of partnering with us, tell
me about what yourself and/or your organisation.
Report 103 is a complimentary weekly electronic newsletter from Bwiti bvba
of Belgium (a jpb.com company: http://www.jpb.com).
Archives and subscription information can be found at http://www.jpb.com/report103/
Report 103 is edited by Jeffrey Baumgartner and is published on the first and
third Tuesday of every month.
You may forward this copy of Report 103 to anyone, provided you forward it
in its entirety and do not edit it in any way. If you wish to reprint only a
part of Report 103, please contact Jeffrey Baumgartner.
Contributions and press releases are welcome. Please contact Jeffrey in the
What People Say About Jeffrey
"Your perspectives are very enlightening... In an ocean
of not-so-useful info about innovation, you manage to get the perls on a regular
basis." EO (Technology manufacturer)
"Thank You for spreading good words." RT (Artist)
"Thank you for sharing your ideas and insights and good
energy with all us creative folks round the world." JS (US state government)
"Always an inspiring newsletter." SL (Executive
"Thanks and keep up the great work." WN (Microelectronics
"Thank you for your thoughts. Quite refreshing.
I am such a fan of the Report 103." LM (Software company)
"You do absolutely amazing work and provide valuable content
as a gift - Thank You." HT (Business strategist)
"I love your newsletter - it is thought provoking and
creates a good energy." IM (Innovation facilitator)
"I have printed all your reports for my PhD thesis in
innovation and creativity. Amazing work, I really wish to congratulate you for
this magnificent effort." RF (PhD student)
"I just got my first copy of your newsletter. Wow! It's
wonderful! Very good advice, very helpful. Thank you! One of the few newsletters
I get that is worth reading and actually useful, thoughtful and inspired. Thank
you!" BB (Publisher)
"Your work is always well done, and thought provoking."
Boost the creativity of your team and the innovativeness of your company by hiring Jeffrey to facilitate an ACT, innovation implementation plan or other workshop with you!
Jeffrey's Book: The Way of the Innovation Master
If you've enjoyed reading Report 103, you will enjoy Jeffrey's book,
The Way of the Innovation Master even more!